Tuesday, September 16, 2008
Determinism Vs. the Individualistic Naturalism of the Soul
“Humanism is a progressive philosophy of life that, without supernaturalism, affirms our ability and responsibility to lead ethical lives of personal fulfillment that aspire to the greater good of humanity.” Tom Clark http://www.centerfornaturalism.org/presentations.htm
Responsibility to aspire to the greater good? Well, then I'm glad I'm not a commie naturalist. I am not even implying that Tom Clark is a collectivist in any way, shape, or form. I don't know the man's politics. But after all, "the greater good" is Communism, as opposed to "promoting the general Welfare," which is American Constitutionalism. And that is a not a parsing of the terminology. So why use such terminology?
While Marx said violence in and of itself is not a good thing, he admitted it may at times be necessary to achieve a greater good. But the promotion of the general welfare requires the protection of the individual from violence initiated by others. The use of State sanctioned violence "when necessary" is the tyranny of the rulers over the ruled--for the ostensible benefit of those who are ruled.
And ostensibly, the "humanist naturalism" Clark promotes is because he wants to "affirm our ability and responsibility to lead ethical lives of personal fulfillment that aspire to the greater good of humanity.” So we have an ethical responsibility, Clark is saying, to look for personal fulfillment no where but in the squelching of individuality. If we were to look for it in the affirmation of individuality, it would destroy the ethics.
Why do I take the critical and extreme path of making the Clark look like an anti-individualist? Because he speaks in the most general of "mushy" soft terminology so that he can not be pinned down as to just what he means--unless you read between the lines."[W]e [need to] live in the light of the empirical truth about ourselves; we don’t need another way of knowing that [which] applies to personal concerns or ultimate concerns. This simplifies things."
What is this "empirical truth" that is opposed to "personal concerns?" According to some of his highly esteemed contributors, the empirical truth is "memes" and "genes" and "environment." Clark mentions the environment on this website; no where did I see him bring in the rest of the "empirical truth" his well-known members insist are real.
Why should personal concerns not be of importance? Because personal concerns get in the way of the common good, without which we can have no ethically personal self-fulfillment!
Naturalism," he says, "affords superior prediction and control of our environment and ourselves, since in dropping the soul and free will we get rid of the fictional supernatural agency that blocks true explanations of phenomena." How does the state, or an organization, "control" the environment for "the common good" which is made of people who ought to have no personal concerns except those of the common good?
Clark admits his naturalistic world-view is probably for the 25th Century because it will take a lot of "education"--or should it be called "re-education"--before we see the idealism of which he dreams. So it may be assumed he does not advocate State-promoted violence in order to accomplish any of his goals. But others of his world-view, those who are also looking at "the common good," do not feel this way. As I wrote in a column last week, the "WeCanSolveIt" campaign that is all over TV is a direct offshoot and is supported by Al Gore's environmental campaign. That can only mean government controls, since he isn't talking the 25th Century; Gore is talking ten years.
Tom Clark's vision of "progressive humanistic naturalism" defines free will as "supernatural." If individuals do not have free will, what do they have that Clark defines as "natural"? He says what is "natural" is that we are "fully caused to want what we want, and to be who we are."
Everything he says is obfuscation. "Fully caused" means that what we "want" and "who we are" are the result of things not in our control, those pesky memes and genes and environmental factors that "fully cause" us. "
"If we reproduced the exact circumstances that obtained at a given time and place, the same behavior would arise: so, in any given situation, we couldn’t have done otherwise, on this view. This means we can’t take ultimate credit or blame for what we do."
He means, if you had something to do all over again, went back in time and encountered the same circumstances, you never would have thought of a different course of action. This is not because in going back we are repeating history. It is because "we are not the ultimate originators of our behavior, but simply the most proximate cause, and other causes surround us in time and space." In time and space we are fully caused by things not in our control, which affect our choices, thereby leaving "free will" to be not only "supernatural" (to be explained below,) but leaving free will to be anything but free.
Why are we not the "ultimate originators of our behavior"?
"According to [the] sciences, we are more or less deterministic, organic, evolved systems, fully embedded within natural causality; so the bottom line is that the empirical debate about free will is essentially over."
There again, Clark uses that non-differential phrasing that means nothing. He says we are "more or less" deterministic. Which is it? And why are we deterministic, if indeed we are? Because the "other causes that surround us in time and space" determine who and what we are for us.
He says we are "organic, evolved systems." That is stating the obvious. We are not rock or gas; we are organic. Does this help his argument? It merely gives it a weightier preponderance of overspeak.
He says we are "fully embedded within natural causality." I'd venture to say we could not be half embedded, or one-tenth embedded, or two-hundred percent embedded. But what does it mean to be embedded "within natural causality?"
Clark uses that phrasing over and over as some sort of mantra, trying to dispell the soul as something man is predisposed to think of as supernatural. It is his goal to "embed" us so deeply into the "natural full-causality" of our determined lives as un-free members of the "common good" that individualism and the knowledge of what we call soul--no matter what it turns out to be be--is dismissed by us as the equivalent of mythology.
"Thanks to neuroscience, there are vastly fewer gaps these days in which the soul can hide." The soul is not an empirical existent, as Clark leads us to infer, something he says we believe is supernaturally reified and existing as something separate and apart from the biology of the human body, floating around it, causing our bodies or our minds to do things while we go on blindly believing that we have free will in order to fulfull the agency of the soul.
It is true that anyone with a belief in traditional religion believes something along these lines. Even Deists believe it. But naturalists don't have to give up defining a "soul" we know exists even by any other name they may choose to give it. We naturalists don't believe it is supernatural. So we naturalists don't believe it is "implanted" supernaturally or otherwise. We believe something exists that has been called soul and is defined as supernatural, but is not supernatural and is the result of our biology. We don't have to search off the beaten track for "memes" and "genes" and environmental agents as "causes" of behavior which are unchangable even if we went back in time to do something all over again.
The soul is precisely that which Clark claims neuroscience dispells: the neurological mechanics of the human organ in its entirety, the act of consciousness looking in upon itself and "feeling" its position in the world, knowing it must decide right from wrong on the basis of extant circumstances.
On that account he is correct; we must make all our decisions based on extant circumstances, on things that we have no control over, such as the light turning red when we're in a hurry to get to work but forcing us to stop, for example. We have no free will to run the light? Why not? We have no free will to calm down by saying the Serenity Prayer? Why not? We have no free will to explode with road rage and scream obscenities at the light and the city that put it there, and at the people going in other directions who didn't have to stop? Why not? Why don't we have the free will to act otherwise than we would have?
Adherents of determinism like him say that determinism is disbelieved by people such as myself because of three lies, "God, immortality, and free will [ ] joined together in a religious narrative, founded in medieval theological dogma [. ] The narrative goes like this: the universe is governed by an all-powerful benevolent spiritual entity – God – who implants a spiritual essence into people at some point following conception. It is this spiritual essence, the soul, that gives people two unique gifts – gifts they did not get from evolution and do not share with any other animal or plant. These two uniquely human spiritual God-given gifts are free will in this life and immortality in the next. According to traditional religion, it is because we have souls that we can transcend the influences of genes and environment, and even triumph over death itself, as our souls fly back up to heaven." Robert Gulack http://www.ethicalfocus.org/index.php?mpage=34/Free_Will.htm
Well, that was not the naturalistic world view of the soul before St. Augustine, but the pre-Augustinian Naturalists did not believe that the soul was implanted by the ruler of the universe. They were well aware of what we now call the "tabula rasa" mind, and that as the mind fills with metaphysical entities, so grows the soul based upon our evaluation of the specific entities we have come to comprehend. They did believe the soul was supernatural, and that it was transcendal of time and space.
They did believe the soul "flew back up to heaven," or some such nonsense as that. But if neuroscience is proving that there is no "implanted" entity we can wrap our minds around, it certainly is proving that what we can wrap our minds around is the idea that emotions are caused by the firing of neurons and the resultant chemical and electrical reactions in our central nervous system.
I've always said the soul is nothing more than the manifestation of the central nervous system, a manifestation of which we are aware within our cognitive capacities. But manifestations can be positively identified, and if the firing of neurons when we are faced with a decision, and the resultant firing of more neurons when we make that decision, can be located within our being it does not have to have the identity of "supernatural" when everything that exists as its cause is necessarily "natural." It is for the greater good of mankind that we identify the soul as individualistic, and neither "contra-causal" or "compatibilist", except that the harder I look the less luck I have finding an actual denotation of either phrase as it relates to free will. "Contra-causal" seems to be a floating abstraction not found in dictionaries but imbued with the anti-virtue of leaving man powerless.
The soul is natural, as natural as the fingernails on your hand, and was no more put inside you at conception by something that supercedes "natural" than your fingernails were implanted supernaturally. But they both exist.
I think Clark has things backward, but for the life of me I don't know how he got it that way. Since our souls are not supernatural, since they are nothing but neurons firing and the resultant emotional responses, then doesn't that indicate individualism, rather than "being one" with nature?
But whether the determinist takes it as "oneness" or or the metaphysical naturalists such as myself takes it to support individualism, neither idea leads to the ethical conclusion that "personal fulfillment [is to] aspire to the greater good of humanity." That aspiration is a very individualistic choice, and has nothing to do with causes which may be out of our control.
Publishing Note:
I have made the attempt several times to allow the posting of reader comments to this blog. I have followed all the directions set by Google (yes, I've read the directions, several times,) but as of yet it isn't working. If you wish to comment, please email them to the address below. Thank you.
Please send all comments to
mailto:freeassemblage@gmail.com
http://freeassemblage.blogspot.com/
The Free Assemblage of Metaphysical Naturalists is the sm of the
Academy of Metaphysical Naturalism tm, the educational arm of the Assemblage.
This publication © 2008 by Curtis Edward Clark and Naturalist Academy Publishing ®
Tuesday, September 9, 2008
Natural Capitalism; Determinism, Compatibalism, Free Will; Wm.Penn
In the Export of Individual Liberty
"Ever since [Bush speechwriter Michael] Gerson wrote for Bush the words “There is another destructive mindset: the idea that if government would only get out of the way, all our problems would be solved. An approach with no higher goal, no nobler purpose than ‘Leave us alone,’” the Republican party has been eagerly embracing openhanded government." http://us.mc590.mail.yahoo.com/mc/showMessage;_ylt=Am9Gzb3X1ZB_SKxLI.suGENjk70X?mid=1_4359_AP5kxEIAAMyJSMFMLAlD4WQJs48&fid=Inbox&sort=date&order=down&startMid=0&.rand=1553591601&da=0
Naturalism in economics requires capitalism. "Capitalism is a social system based on the recognition of individual rights..." wrote Ayn Rand. "The recognition of individual rights entails the banishment of physical force from human relationships: basically, rights can be violated only by means of force." from Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal
Now, coming from Rand, there are people who will automatically discount this idea of equating "freedom" with "capitalism," especially those who don't see the connection Rand or not. But, the initiation of force, as opposed to its use in self-defence, can never be justified, and thus is never moral. Man lives by reason alone, or he has no justification for anything, objectively speaking.
Then, too, there are those who claim that morals are relative, whatever that means. Actually, it means whatever its proponent wants it to mean; whereas objective morals are based in the nature of Man as the "rational animal," with the objective standards for his existence being those of "qua Man." http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/qua
"Capitalism and Freedom is a book by Milton Friedman originally published in 1962 which discusses the role of economic capitalism in liberal society. [ ] Friedman makes the case for economic freedom as a precondition for political freedom. He defines liberal in European Enlightenment terms, contrasting with an American usage that he believes has been corrupted since the Great Depression. " [italics added] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism_and_Freedom
"[Adam] Smith's great revelation was that political freedom would most likely emerge and persist under conditions of economic freedom, what we now call capitalism. Our democratic system as defined in our Constitution incorporated respect for this economic system.
"More than the export of democracy, it is the export of entrepreneurial
capitalism that can produce a new birth of peace and freedom around our globe.
Entrepreneurial capitalism is based on individual invention, and because wealth
comes from one's own initiative, it advances human dignity.
"And here is the good news. Virtually every country, whatever its political system, wants to embrace it. They have seen the success of the American economy.
"It has been said that when goods cross borders, armies don't. Today, China and India are the world's two largest countries racing toward entrepreneurial capitalism. They are the example and test of that thesis. Several decades ago, their armies clashed. Now no one talks of war, only of their economic emergence. Capitalism has promoted peace and, in China, better — though still inadequate — respect for rights." Carl J. Schramm; USA Today http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2006-06-27-capitalism_x.htm
"Capitalism is defined as, 1: An economic system characterized by private or corporate ownership of capital goods, by investments that are determined by private decisions, and by prices, production, and the distribution of goods that are determined mainly by competition in the free market." Mike Wasdin http://www.strike-the-root.com/4/wasdin/wasdin28.html
In the Academy of MN's blog's description of The Nature of Human Nature,
http://freeassemblage.blogspot.com/2008/08/nature-of-human-nature.html , it is made clear that "man's ethical values, compulsions, activities, and restraints can be justified on natural grounds," and that "his highest good [is] pursued and attained under natural conditions." "Qua Man" includes anything that was known true of man qua man when Aristotle coined the phrase, to what rational, ontological, metaphysical naturalism (or Objectivism, which are not the same) determine it to be. Why? Because those two philosophies do not degrade Man, they raise him up from the mud that other philosophies squash him into.
Anything less than capitalism, whereby economic goals are neither restricted nor determined by the coercive forces of government, is not an economy of freedom.
Semantics; Determinism and Free Will as Necessary Concomitants
At the top of this blog page, in what is called the "site description" right underneath the site "title" which are both in the orange areas, the "description" is this: "Ontological rationality in secular Naturalism. "Existence is Identity, Consciousness is Identification." Ayn Rand"
This was not the first description I used, and I can't now remember what it was. It doesn't matter; it was lame. It was lame because the more I came to know about Naturalism, the more I realized how divided it was, how semantic could be the users of the terms. I change that description to be more denotational according my concept of it; but concepts of this nature are not easy to integrate without contradiction.
Some Naturalists claim ontology is not compatible with Naturalism; but the world "compatibalism" has nothing to do with that, yet "compatibalism" is one of those semantic divisions within the field. Compatibalism concerns the issue of "free will."
An "ontological object" is defined in this context as, "The real or existing object of an act of knowledge as distinguished from the epistemological object." Dict. of Phil; Runes; http://www.ditext.com/runes/o.html And so what I mean by placing that statement in the description of the purpose of the Academy of MN, is to say that not only metaphysics but naturalism are objects of an act of knowledge, not acts of brain physiology acting in accord with genetics, environment, and the laws of nature.
When the semantics become overwhelming (see the AofMN blog 9.5.08 "Variations on a Theme of Naturalism) they destroy the nature of knowledge by splitting it into incompatible and almost irreconcilable fragments, over which men argue and refuse to find compromise (where that compromise is not compromise of principles, of course.)
Hopefully, by pointing out how "compatibalism" on the subject of free will, and free will in context of "determinism" can explain free will and compatibalism at the same time as necessary concomitants, is a compromise the two sides can accept.
"The problem of free choice can stand at the same place, it is changing. There were proposed two main conceptions which have the powers to produce some kind of solution the problem. So, there are the conception of determinism and the conception of compatibalism. Let’s see the essence of these two conceptions. But before we start the descriptive talking it is very important to be sure that we have a certain question concerning a free choice. The notion of a free choice and just a choice can be regarded as synonyms. The meaning of choice is rather general; it means the decision that could be done by the person. So, such under the necessary interpretation of choice we see action of the person and it turned to be a kind of guide line for us. Well, the problem of free choice lies on the next statement: whether we are able to choose or not. If we remember that choice is a kind of decision, we should redo the question and ask whether we are able to make a decision at a certain period of time without using different alternative prepositions which could be limited." ANDREW SCHWARTZ http://www.amazines.com/Art_and_Culture/article_detail.cfm/327934?articleid=327934 [Note: It would seem English is not Mr. Schwartz's first language. All grammatical errors are his. This quote is a literal cut/paste.]
But this next author equates it with God being in control.
"I cannot count the number of times that I have heard or read the phrase.."God is in control..." This phrase can be recited in connection with everything from death and disease to happiness and health and everything else in between. Do we really believe, as Christians, that God IS in control..or is it just "lip service"? Is it just religious lingo or is it a firmly held and scripturally understood belief? Compatibalism attempts to explain how it is that "God IS in control AND that human responsibility and accountability is also in full effect. We see this supposed dichotomy in full view in the following scripture: (Jesus) "..being delivered by the determinate counsel and foreknowledge of God, ye have taken , and by wicked hands have crucified and slain." Dave Van http://areformedlaymansperspective.blogspot.com/2008/06/compatibalism.html
Ok, so most of the semantics discern "compatibalism" against "determinism." The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (SEP) says, "Causal determinism is, roughly speaking, the idea that every event is necessitated by antecedent events and conditions together with the laws of nature." http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/determinism-causal/
Roughly speaking this means that we are not free to make choices of free will, because every choice open to us is "determined" by the events of the world around us.
Well, that is absolutely true--the part about what our choices are. We can't decide to order a T-bone steak at McDonald's; we can't decide to take aspirin for depression; we can't decide to refuse to pay child support when the court ordered its payment unless we are willing to go to jail. And if we are willing to go to jail for it, we are not free in our will to avoid jail; the choices are laid out by the circumstances around us.
In spite of these "deterministic" machinations of the universe upon our desire to be free of them, it is precisely the world around us that give us choices in the first place! No world; no choices. No choices; no consciousness. Consciousness itself consists of choices that are put before us at birth, namely to start identifying the objects of cognition (which are technically called cognoscenti); which means that in the semantics of "determinism" we have no "free choice" because the choices are the cognoscenti placed before us. A newborn cannot decide to identify a basketball because its not his choice.
"Existence is Identity, Consciousness is Identification."
On the other hand, "When it comes to applying his knowledge, man decides what he chooses to do, according to what he has learned, remembering that the basic principle of rational action in all aspects of human existence, is: “Nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed.” This means that man does not create reality and can achieve his values only by making his decisions consonant with the facts of reality." [italics added]
Ayn Rand; “Who Is the Final Authority in Ethics?”; The Objectivist Newsletter
The facts of reality are those placed before us by the existence of existents, be it a thing, an attribute or an action; i.e., by those things in life which cause men the need to make choices in the first place. If you were the only existent in existence, you would have no choices. But you are not. Everything in your environment is an existent, and as concepts so are the things in your mind upon which you may make choices.
Free will is the freedom to think or not to think, Rand said.
Another word with semantic distinctions is "selfish." OMG! What exactly does "selfish" mean? The Tibetans are said to have two words for it, whereas in English we have two complicated definitions, not two words with their own simple definition. The Tibetans have these:
1. Selfishness is taking advantage of others and not caring, (or something to that effect. Feel free to put it in your own vocabulary, because everyone knows precisely their own opinion about this subject.
2. Rational self-interest.
Rational self-interest as a definition of selfishness; who these days would have thought, had it already not been thought of and much discussed over the many decades, if not longer. Such self-interest is "the promotion of one’s own interests [as] always in accordance with reason." http://www.iep.utm.edu/e/egoism.htm But "in accordance" itself has implications as a semantic division.
"Epistemologically, [objectivity] is the recognition of the fact that a perceiver’s (man’s) consciousness must acquire knowledge of reality by certain means (reason) in accordance with certain rules (logic)." [italics added] Ayn Rand; “Who Is the Final Authority in Ethics?”; The Objectivist Newsletter
Yet, in another place Rand wrote, "[The] valid definition of man, within the context of his knowledge and of all of mankind’s knowledge to-date [is]: 'A rational animal.'
(Rational,” in this context, does not mean 'acting invariably in accordance with reason'; it means 'possessing the faculty of reason.' [italics added] Rand Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology These distinctions are vitally important to understanding the place of reason in the life of man, and how it is to be applied, and in what contexts.
"The idea of determinism is ancient, but first became subject to clarification and mathematical analysis in the eighteenth century. Determinism is deeply connected with our understanding of the physical sciences and their explanatory ambitions, on the one hand, and with our views about human free action on the other. In both of these general areas there is no agreement over whether determinism is true (or even whether it can be known true or false), and what the import for human agency would be in either case." [SEP ibid]
No, there can be no agreement so long as the two sides argue over semantics. It was my attempt to dispel the dichotomy when I said, above, "it is precisely the world around us that give us choices in the first place! No world; no choices. No choices; no consciousness." A consciousness with nothing to be conscious of is a contradiction in terms, Rand famously said. (Aside from "Who is John Galt?" it might be the second most famous thing she ever said.)
Determinism is true only in the sense that we have no choices but those given us by the circumstances of existence itself; and equally true that without such choices arbitrarily given to us by life, without any bias on its part, we would not exist.
It is the amoeba and other simple forms of life, forms that have no "conscious" sense of choices, that are ruled by determinism. Man must accept that his choices are determined, but at the same time, he has the choice to think or not to think.
William Penn* on Learning
-338-
5. The first Thing obvious to Children is what is sensible; and that we make no Part of their rudiments.
6. We press their Memory too soon, and puzzle, strain, and load them with Words and Rules; to know Grammer and Rhetorick, and a strange Tongue or two, that it is ten to one may never be useful to them; Leaving their natural Genius to Mechanical and Physical, or natural Knowledge uncultivated and neglected; which would be of exceeding Use and Pleasure to them through the whole Course of their Life.
7. To be sure, Languages are not to be despised or neglected. But Things are still to be preferred. 9. It were Happy if we studied Nature more in natural Things; and acted according to Nature; whose rules are few, plain and most reasonable.
10. Let us begin where she begins, go her Pace, and close always where she ends, and we cannot miss of being good Naturalists.
-339-
15. It is pity therefore that Books have not been composed for Youth, by some curious and careful Naturalists, and also Mechanicks, in the Latin Tongue, to be used in Schools, that they might learn Things with Words: Things obvious and familiar to them, and which would make the Tongue easier to be obtained by them.
16. Many able Gardiners and Husbandmen are yet Ignorant of the Reason of their Calling as most Artificers are of the Reason of their own Rules that govern their excellent Workmanship. But a Naturalist and Mechanick of this sort is Master of the Reason of both, and might be of the Practice too, if his Industry kept pace with his Speculation; which were very commendable; and without which he cannot be said to be a complete Naturalist or Mechanick.
17. Finally, if Man be the Index or Epitomy of the World, as Philosophers tell us, we have only to read our selves well to be learned in it.
* William Penn (October 14, 1644 – July 30, 1718) was founder and "Absolute Proprietor" of the Province of Pennsylvania, the English North American colony and the future U.S. state of Pennsylvania. He was known as an early champion of democracy and religious freedom and famous for his good relations and his treaties with the Lenape Indians. Under his direction, Philadelphia was planned and developed.
As one of the earlier supporters of colonial unification, Penn wrote and urged for a Union of all the English colonies in what was to become the United States of America. The democratic principles that he set forth in the Pennsylvania Frame(s) of Government served as an inspiration for the United States Constitution. As a pacifist Quaker, Penn considered the problems of war and peace deeply, and included a plan for a United States of Europe, "European Dyet, Parliament or Estates," in his voluminous writings. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Penn
Please send all comments to
mailto:freeassemblage@gmail.com
http://freeassemblage.blogspot.com/
The Free Assemblage of Metaphysical Naturalists is the sm of the
Academy of Metaphysical Naturalism tm, the educational arm of the Assemblage.
This publication © 2008 by Curtis Edward Clark and Naturalist Academy Publishing ®

